Here are some factors
to consider when evaluating web sites for academic research:
Criteria |
Suggestions
for how to determine if the webpage or site meets the criteria |
Content Is your topic
covered? Is the information
accurate? |
·
Look in
the menus provided to see if any of them might lead you to information about
your topic ·
It’s not
always easy to know if the information on a web page is correct, so compare
the information with what you find in other sources, such as encyclopedias,
books, and magazine and newspaper articles. ·
Look at
spelling and grammar – if the author was not careful to make sure the
spelling and grammar were correct, the author may not have made sure the
information was correct either. |
Authority Who’s the author? Who’s the publisher? Is there a list of
sources? Is this an
appropriate source for your research? For
example, is a cigarette company web site a good place to get information
about lung cancer? Is a web page
created by a 5th grade class a good place to find information
about air pollution? |
·
Look for
author information, such as name, contact information, educational and
professional background, at either the top or the bottom of the page. If there’s no author information there,
check the site’s home page for a list of staff that might provide more
details. ·
Look for
publisher (company or organization) information: ·
In the web address (for example, www.sony.com is sponsored by Sony). ·
At the
bottom of the web page. ·
On the
web site’s main/home page – there may be a link that says something like “About
us” or
“Welcome” or “Who we are.” Look for mission statements, history,
contact information, and other organizations the company is associated with.
·
Look at the domain name
(.com, .edu, .org, .gov) to determine what kind of organization or company
sponsors the site. |
Purpose What is the mission
of the site/company? Are any biases or
opinions clearly stated? Is the site trying
to educate you, entertain you, sell you something, or convince you of
something? |
·
Check
the “About Us” or “Who We Are” section, which is usually on the site’s main
page. |
Date |
·
The date
of last update is typically found at the bottom of a web page; if you don’t
see it on the web page you’re viewing, check the site’s main page to see if a
date is provided there. |
Level of Difficulty |
·
Is the
vocabulary too technical or too scholarly for your purposes? ·
Is the
vocabulary to elementary for college-level research? |