ENG 112 College Composition II                                         Nancy McTaggart
Home Course Information Unit 1 Unit 2 Unit 3 Exam   1 Unit 4 FInal Exam


You chose the following answer to Question 3: 

Choice d)  Through her depiction of Mrs. Mallard's husband, Kate Chopin justifies Mrs. Mallard's joy in her husband's death.   

This argument is unrelated to the thesis statement:  "Through the story Chopin communicates that even if women believe they are happily married,  the "joy" of marriage destroys a significant part of them."  The thesis does not include the concept of justification, so the argument is irrelevant in this essay.  It does not increase the likelihood that the reader will accept the validity of the thesis.

Of the remaining choices, which is the best thesis statement?

      Choice a)   Mrs. Mallard experiences many different emotions when she learns that her husband is dead.

     Choice b)   The progression of emotions that Mrs. Mallard feels when told of her husband's death shows that she was unaware of her true feelings about marriage.

    Choice c)  Mrs. Mallard is upset when she learns her husband is dead.